The Too Perfect Alibi

Originally Aired: January 13, 1949

Suspense #323, "The Too Perfect Alibi," stars Danny Kaye as Sam Rogers, a man hopelessly in love with Catherine, the woman of his dreams. When Catherine and her fiancé Jack Stewart announce they're getting married on Monday, Sam's world shatters. Catherine is lovely and kind, while Jack is a handsome former football hero now working as a clerk in a sports shop. Despite his resentment of Sam's generosity and wealth, Jack accepts Sam's offer of help securing a lucrative position as sales manager at Allegheny Sporting Goods, asking only that Catherine not know about Sam's involvement. What Jack doesn't realize is that Sam has no intention of helping him get the job.

Consumed by jealousy and desperation, Sam hatches an elaborate plan to eliminate his rival before the Monday wedding. He carefully constructs what he believes is the perfect alibi, attending a party where he makes sure to be seen by numerous guests throughout the evening. At precisely ten o'clock, Sam slips away to meet Jack under a dark tree on a street corner, his murderous scheme ready to unfold.